This is a book you can read in one sitting. It's fast-paced and an entertaining read. I'm not always a fan of the magical realism genre as a whole, but I like books that make you think. Alfie has the ability to re-do a moment lived and make a different decision. He can only do this once for each specific situation and if he chooses to do it again a different way, he has to live with that. He can't re-live any moment more than twice. So, if you think of all those embarrassing moments in your life that you wished you could erase, Alfie could do that. I'm not sure I would have used this "talent" as often as Alfie did however. It's one thing to go back and make a different decision than you did a few minutes ago, but it's another thing to go back days, weeks, months, or years. Honestly, it's only in the most dire circumstances that I would want to re-live months or years of my life! One thing Alfie could never change however, is someone's death. If someone was fated to die at any given moment, than that would happen no matter what Alfie did.
One key element with this ability concerns love. Alfie is told by his mother, who also had this gift, that he can't go back and recreate the same love if he chooses to do it again. She had learned this the hard way, losing forever her one true love, which wasn't Alfie's father. Of course Alfie does it anyway and is deeply saddened by the loss of his one true love. When is comes to his marriage to Gianna, Alfie comes across as very selfish. This bothered me. Gianna had wanted to be a photographer her entire life. Gianna & Alfie had first met in Africa when they were children. Alfie and his parents were living in Africa as missionaries. Alfie & Gianna connected over their love of an elephant. When Alfie's mother died, he and his father left Africa. Alfie & Gianna met again years later as adults and fell in love. Gianna pretty much gave up her dreams in life, such as being an international photographer of wildlife and having children, for Alfie. Alfie wanted what Alfie wanted. When their marriage starts to suffer (go figure!), Alfie lusts after an actress and decides to go for it instead of trying to make his marriage work with Gianna. Since Alfie had to re-do his original decision not to sleep with the actress, he loses his life with Gianna and her love for him. Lesson learned.
Some key lessons in the book:
Lesson 1: "...what we yearn for, deep down, is a heart that will embrace us after we make a fool of ourselves." Alfie needed to understand that unconditional love is demonstrated when the people we love still love us despite our faults and failures. True love is not about being perfect and never making mistakes.
Lesson 2: Life should be lived in the present tense. If you live in the present tense, "You pay closer attention to things. You're more appreciative. More accepting."
Lesson 3: "'Would you do anything differently if you had the chance?'" Mitch Albom responds, "I can think of twenty things right now. But ask me if I'd trade how I'd changed as a result of my mistakes, and my answer would be different." "If you keep getting second chances, you won't learn a damn thing. I've learned a lot. The older I get, the more precious those lessons become." True story.
I'm ambiguous about the ending. I am more of a "learn from my mistakes and move on" kind of gal, rather than rehashing what's already happened. To each their own.
Wendy's Rating: ****